i’ll try and get the comments for you also

John
Celebridiot

The “I Shot the Sheriff” performance proves that Jason’s being a poseur with the dreds. I don’t know who his musically exactly, but he ain’t no Reggae artist. If he wan’ts long hair, cool, but something else.

As to the lyrics thing, Brooke did it twice, so I have to cut him some slack. At least he just kept on going (Jason, it’s “in the jingle jangle morning I’ll be following you.”). I actually liked that song better with him doing it than with Dylan doing it, but it did show his critical weakness which is that he is a performer of songs not an interpreter of songs and he doesn’t know who he is musically. I can’t say Syesha is much stronger in that regard, however, so we’ll see.

I wanted to let you know first that you goofed slightly on Syesha — both links lead to the same song. Where are David Cook’s judges comments?

I haven’t seen Jason’s clips yet, but I have to say that I’m very partial to him and I hope he isn’t gone. At the same time, I recognize that it seems like for the last several weeks, he’s been performing like he takes his success for granted. I’d like to see him come back next week and put the naysayers to rest.