Which hopeful got sent home tonight???
Carly Smithson!
How Brooke and Jason survived this week is beyond me….voters got this one wrong. I don’t think Carly had a shot of winning, but she was more entertaining than the other choices. Idol is left with four boring ballad singers and David Cook – gee who do you think is going to stand out?
Videos
Top 6 Perform All I Ask of You
<