Who went home on Idol?

Posted on April 23rd, 2008

Which hopeful got sent home tonight???

Carly Smithson!

How Brooke and Jason survived this week is beyond me….voters got this one wrong. I don’t think Carly had a shot of winning, but she was more entertaining than the other choices. Idol is left with four boring ballad singers and David Cook – gee who do you think is going to stand out?

Videos
Top 6 Perform All I Ask of You

Carly Smithson Elimination

Leona Lewis Performs